When to pick FSC
Specify FSC for any paper product sold internationally, particularly to European customers, for premium consumer packaging, or for brands with global sustainability claims. FSC is the label most retail buyers and consumers recognize.
When to pick SFI
Specify SFI when buying North American paper for North American distribution. SFI is PEFC-endorsed so it counts for PEFC-compliant supply chains. Many large US and Canadian mills carry SFI by default, with FSC as an upgrade.
The decision in one paragraph
For domestic US and Canadian paper supply, SFI is sufficient and often cheaper. For products crossing into Europe, ask for FSC. Many mills hold both; when you're specifying, ask for the logo your end customer or retailer requires.
Frequently asked questions
Is SFI recognized in Europe?
SFI is endorsed by PEFC, so SFI-labeled paper can be sold as PEFC compliant in Europe. However, European retailers often still prefer the direct FSC or PEFC label over SFI.
Is SFI easier to get than FSC?
Generally yes. SFI's audit framework is often perceived as less stringent on social and indigenous-rights criteria, and SFI-certified forests are more available in North America.
Can a mill hold both FSC and SFI?
Yes. Most large North American mills carry both concurrently. Dual certification costs more but gives maximum buyer coverage.